America's Two Dominant Pharmacy Chains — and How They Differ for NNN Investors
CVS Health (9,700+ stores) and Walgreens Boots Alliance (9,000+ US stores) together represent approximately 40% of all US pharmacy dispensing volume. For NNN investors, both chains have historically offered 20-year lease terms, absolute NNN structures, and investment-grade corporate guarantees.
But 2023–2025 has brought significant divergence in their credit stories — creating meaningfully different risk/reward profiles for investors today.
CVS Health: The Integrated Healthcare Giant
Business Model
CVS transformed from a pure pharmacy retailer into a vertically integrated healthcare company through acquisitions: CVS Caremark (pharmacy benefit management, $26B revenue), Aetna ($70B acquisition, health insurance), and MinuteClinic (4,100+ in-store healthcare clinics). This diversification makes CVS substantially less dependent on retail pharmacy than Walgreens.
Credit Profile
CVS Health carries an S&P BBB credit rating — investment-grade. While their debt load from acquisitions is substantial, their diversified revenue streams and consistent free cash flow generation provide strong debt coverage.
NNN Lease Structure
CVS typically signs 25-year initial NNN leases — among the longest in the pharmacy sector. Rent escalations are modest (typically flat for the initial term, then 5–10% increases in option periods). Their absolute NNN structure means zero landlord responsibilities.
Cap Rates
CVS cap rates: 5.25–6.5% in primary markets, 6.0–7.25% in secondary markets. For investment-grade quality, these represent reasonable yields with genuine corporate credit backing.
Walgreens: The Turnaround Story
Credit Downgrade: A Critical Development
In 2024, S&P downgraded Walgreens Boots Alliance to BB+ — speculative grade (below investment-grade). This is the most significant credit event in the NNN pharmacy sector in a decade. The downgrade reflected Walgreens' challenges with declining retail pharmacy margins, ongoing store closure program, and management transitions.
What the Downgrade Means for NNN Investors
Existing Walgreens NNN investors with long-term leases are largely unaffected — the lease guarantees don't change. But new buyers must price in higher credit risk, which has pushed Walgreens cap rates to 6.0–7.75% — reflecting the premium investors demand for below-investment-grade credit.
Walgreens has announced the closure of 1,200 stores over 3 years. Properties in weaker retail corridors or with shorter remaining lease terms face higher risk of being included in closure plans.
The Opportunity Angle
Some sophisticated investors see Walgreens' credit challenges as opportunity. At 7.0–7.5% cap rates on 15+ year leases at Walgreens' highest-volume locations, the income yield is compelling. If Walgreens stabilizes (or is acquired), values could appreciate significantly. This is a higher-risk, higher-potential-reward position than traditional NNN investing.
Side-by-Side Comparison
| Factor | CVS | Walgreens |
|---|---|---|
| Credit Rating | BBB (Investment-Grade) | BB+ (Speculative Grade) |
| Stores | 9,700+ | 9,000+ |
| Lease Term | 25 years | 20–25 years |
| Cap Rates (Primary) | 5.25–6.5% | 6.0–7.5% |
| Store Closures | Modest (900 over 3 years) | Aggressive (1,200 over 3 years) |
| Business Diversification | High (Aetna, Caremark) | Low (primarily retail pharmacy) |
The Verdict
For conservative 1031 exchange investors seeking safety: CVS is the clear choice. Investment-grade credit, diversified business model, and reasonable cap rates make CVS the pharmacy NNN standard.
For yield-focused investors comfortable with higher risk: Walgreens' high-volume locations with long remaining lease terms offer compelling returns. Rigorous site-by-site analysis is essential — not all Walgreens NNN properties are equivalent risk.
Contact The ESS Group to access current CVS and Walgreens NNN inventory with site-specific performance analysis.
Ready to Invest?
Our advisors specialize in sourcing premium off-market NNN properties for high-net-worth investors and 1031 exchanges. Contact The ESS Group to see available inventory.